Judging Criteria
Transparent evaluation framework ensuring fair and comprehensive assessment of all submissions.
Scoring Breakdown
Our judges evaluate projects across four key dimensions, each weighted to reflect their importance in cybersecurity innovation.
How strong and meaningful the core idea is.
Evaluation Points
- Is the problem real and relevant?
- Is the solution novel or significantly better than existing solutions?
- Does the team clearly explain why the problem matters?
Examples
- 1–3: Generic idea, unclear problem
- 4–7: Reasonable idea but common
- 8–10: Unique or deeply relevant concept
Working prototype, code quality, and technical difficulty.
Evaluation Points
- Working prototype
- Code quality and architecture
- Security practices
- Technical difficulty
- Effective use of frameworks / APIs
Examples
- 1–3: Barely functional or mostly theoretical
- 4–7: Working prototype with moderate complexity
- 8–10: Robust, technically impressive implementation
Deployable solutions and practical tools.
Evaluation Points
- Can this realistically be used in production?
- Does it solve a real-world security / AI / web problem?
- Is it scalable?
Examples
- 1–3: Mostly conceptual
- 4–7: Could be useful with improvements
- 8–10: Immediately valuable or highly scalable
How original the solution is.
Evaluation Points
- New approach to a known problem
- Clever technical design
- Creative use of technology
Examples
- 1–3: Common or obvious
- 4–7: Some creativity
- 8–10: Truly innovative
How well the team explains their project.
Evaluation Points
- Clarity of explanation
- Demo quality
- Ability to answer technical questions
Examples
- 1–3: Confusing demo
- 4–7: Clear but basic
- 8–10: Excellent explanation and live demo
GitHub + Devpost submission quality.
Evaluation Points
- Clear README
- Setup instructions
- Code documentation
- GitHub structure
Examples
- 1–3: Minimal documentation
- 4–7: Acceptable documentation
- 8–10: Professional open-source quality
How Judging Works
A structured evaluation process ensuring every project receives fair and thorough assessment.
Judges review all submissions and score based on criteria
Top projects are selected for final presentation round
Finalists present live to judges and community
Judges finalize scores and select winners
Key Evaluation Areas
Understanding what makes a winning project across different aspects of cybersecurity innovation.
- Working and functional prototype
- Clean, well-architected codebase
- Implementation of security best practices
- Effective use of modern frameworks and APIs
- Addressing real-world security challenges
- Clear explanation of why the problem matters
- Novelty of the proposed solution
- Significantly better than existing alternatives
- Realistic production implementation
- Scalable architecture and design
- Immediate value to the security community
- Practicality over mere gimmicks
- Clarity and confidence in explanation
- High-quality, stable live demo
- Ability to handle technical deep-dives
- Professional documentation and README
Specialized Criteria
Each track has specific emphasis areas while maintaining the core evaluation framework.
Track Focus
AI/ML in security applications
Special Emphasis
- Defensive AI systems
- AI-assisted monitoring
- Model safety
- Robustness tooling
Track Focus
Network and infrastructure security
Special Emphasis
- Software security
- Infrastructure tools
- Protocol security
- Physical network security
Track Focus
Fun, absurd, but working solutions
Special Emphasis
- Creative execution
- Working prototypes
- Humor and innovation
- Technical depth despite absurdity
Track Focus
High-impact innovative solutions
Special Emphasis
- Real-world applicability
- Technical innovation
- Market impact
- Scalability
Additional Information
Download detailed judging criteria and find answers to common questions about the evaluation process.
Get the complete judging criteria document with detailed explanations and examples.
Download PDFLearn about our expert panel of judges and their backgrounds in cybersecurity.
View Speakers & JudgesJoin the Global Movement
Registration is free and open to builders worldwide. Join 1000+ others in the ultimate security marathon.